News » National

Updated: June 5, 2013 15:23 IST

Implementation issues to hit TDS on property deals

A. Srivathsan
Comment (1)   ·   print   ·   T  T  

It is not clear who will bear the tax and who will be responsible for deducting tax at source

The government proposal to deduct tax at source for property transactions has raised concerns for potential property buyers and sellers alike, and surprised many.

It was only last year, a similar measure was proposed and withdrawn following complaints regarding implementation difficulties. This year again, with no change in remittance infrastructure or attendant problems, the government has introduced TDS (tax deduction at source) of one per cent on the transaction of all immovable properties except agricultural land, which exceeds Rs.50 lakh in value.

K. Suryakanth Shenoy, a chartered accountant based in Chennai, finds this proposal riddled with problems. He said that “it is not clear who will bear the tax and who would be responsible for deduction of tax at source.  If the seller is liable for deduction, the buyer will have to be at the mercy of seller for the TDS certificate. In this case, any delay would mean additional burden of tax, late filing of return or requirement to pay and seek refund. This could also lead to a plethora of litigations. The proposal though looks akin to filing of a simple challan at the time of registration, in reality, it would be more complicated and involve further invisible costs.” The senior citizens, in particular, would face these complications more. Hazels of tax and online remittance could be daunting. Mr. Shenoy further added that “though the move to deduct TDS may be laudable, it saddles the IT department with further returns for scrutiny, additional assessments, claims, demands and refunds and may be more litigations.”

C. Sridhar Varadaraj, Vice-President, Hanu Reddy Realty, said that “this unexpected proposal may curb speculation in high-value real estate markets such as Mumbai and Delhi and lead to more transparency in transactions. It would fill the coffers of the government in the short-term, but would affect the real estate sector on the long term. Compliance issues would make it difficult for every one involved.”

The TDS of 1% for properties costing more than 50 lakhs would be
counter productive. Such transactions can be easily tracked by AIR and
the much touted 360 degree profiling. The TDS will only make the
already cumbersome property sales more TEDIOUS (TDS). Most of the
black money in the country is not in Swiss banks but in the country
itself, in land and apartments. The better thing would be to have a
property exchange just like the stock exchange and all property
transactions be routed through this exchange with a property
transaction tax (PTT) just like STT. This can bring in more revenue to
the Government, make the property transactions more transparent and
easy but with the politicians and government officials owning most of
the black money will somebody bite the bullet?

from:  Monty Doctor
Posted on: Mar 1, 2013 at 09:37 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Economic Survey

More Economic Survey »



Recent Article in National

Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi speaks with farmers, outside his residence in New Delhi on Saturday. Photo: Sandeep Saxena

Rahul Gandhi meets farmers

Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi, who returned home two days back after a 56-day leave of absence, on Saturday met farmers here. »