News » National

Updated: January 7, 2012 12:07 IST

Hooch death toll 148, many battling for lives

Shiv Sahay Singh
Comment (1)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
A patient getting treatment at Diamond Harbour Sub-Divisional hospital on Wednesday. The toll in the hooch tragedy rose to 107 on Thursday. Photo: Arunangsu Roy Chowdhury
The Hindu
A patient getting treatment at Diamond Harbour Sub-Divisional hospital on Wednesday. The toll in the hooch tragedy rose to 107 on Thursday. Photo: Arunangsu Roy Chowdhury

The death toll from consumption of spurious liquor at Sangrampur here shot up to 148 on Thursday, even as 100 other victims were battling for their lives in hospitals.

While over 100 persons have died at the Diamond Harbour sub-divisional hospital since the victims started pouring in on Wednesday, the remaining deaths were reported from other hospitals in the city.

Probe announced

Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee announced a probe into the incident by the State's Criminal Investigation Department. Ten persons who were part of the illicit liquor racket have been arrested.

Chemical analysis will be done of the body fluids of the deceased which are being preserved by forensic experts. Doctors said that along with “methyl alcohol poisoning,” they were suspecting the presence of some chemicals mixed with the alcohol for high intoxication.

Authorities at the sub-divisional hospital found it difficult to cope with the rush of patients, who kept pouring in through the day.

Most of the patients at the 250-bed hospital were lying on the floor, with anxious family members by their side. They were administered saline drips. More than 325 people have been admitted to the hospital since Wednesday. They consumed illicit liquor from hooch dens in Sangrampur and adjoining villages of the sub-division.

“The patients are suffering from an acute stomach pain, blurred vision and nausea. They have been admitted with methyl alcohol toxicity, for treatment of which ventilator is required, but this facility is not available in the hospital,” said Sikha Adhikari, the district's Chief Medical Officer of Health.

A pall of gloom has descended on the hospital. Thousands of distraught people assembled there, many to claim bodies, which were taken out on cyclerickshaw vans after post-mortem.

Locals angry

As the count of the dead kept rising, anger was palpable in the villages against the district administration and the police. Locals at Sangrampur and adjoining villages alleged that illicit liquor dens had been doing a flourishing business in the area over the years. The police did little to clamp down on the dealers, they said.

Irate villagers ransacked the dens at some place and set a few ablaze, alleging that they operated, despite public resentment, because of a nexus between the local police and the illicit trade.

I am shocked by this tragedy and my sympathies are with the victims. One of the ironies is that an antidote for Methyl Alcohol poisoning is Ethyl Alcohol. That is besides the point.Governments may use tragedies of this kind to scrap the prohibition. In that context one should consider the Bayes Theorem which is actually a conditional probability. It is a probability of a probability in effect.Providing unadulterated liquor may cut down the consumption of adulterated liquor and save some lives. However removal of prohibition will make an enormous number of people to drink who would not otherwise drink. Even if only a small number of people consuming " healthy " alcohol were to develop complications that number will far exceed the number of people exposed to adulterated alcohol. Hence removal of prohibition is not a treatment to save lives. More lives will be lost through healthy alcohol than through adulterated alcohol.

from:  T.S.Krishnaswamy
Posted on: Dec 16, 2011 at 03:08 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Avian Influenza Outbreak

More Avian Influenza Outbreak »


Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh





Recent Article in National

A file photo of Vice-President Hamid Ansari in the Rajya Sabha in New Delhi.

Rajya Sabha condemns bail to 26/11 accused Lakhvi

Rajya Sabha on Monday adopted a resolution condemning the bail granted to Mumbai attack mastermind Zaki-ur Rehman Lakhvi and asked Pakis... »