News » National

Updated: August 10, 2012 17:47 IST

Deleting Assam voters on religious basis not possible: Centre tells SC

Comment (7)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Bodo people take rest at a camp in Kokrajhar. The Centre has told the Supreme Court that it would not be possible to delete names of 40 lakh doubtful voters from Assam state. File photo
Bodo people take rest at a camp in Kokrajhar. The Centre has told the Supreme Court that it would not be possible to delete names of 40 lakh doubtful voters from Assam state. File photo

Amid continuing violence in Assam, the Centre has told the Supreme Court that it would not be possible to delete names of 40 lakh doubtful voters from the state on the basis of their religious or linguistic profile as it would be unconstitutional.

The Centre rejected the allegation of NGO Assam Public Works that over 40 lakh illegal migrants from Bangladesh had got their names entered into the electoral rolls and they should forthwith be deported.

In an affidavit placed before a bench of justices P Sathasivam and Ranjan Gogoi on Thursday, the Centre, however, assured the court that it was committed to weed out illegal migrants from the state.

The apex court, while taking on record the affidavit, posted the matter for further hearing to November 6.

“That the proposed modality suggested by the petitioner NGO to identify and delete alleged doubtful voters; from the voter list 2006 based on religious and linguistic profiling is prima facie illegal, arbitrary and violation of secular and democratic fabric of lndia.

“That the prayer made by the petitioner cannot be allowed as it violates the Constitution mandate,” the affidavit filed by the Union Home Ministry said.

The Centre said as a matter of policy it does not support any kind of illegal migration either into its territory or illegal immigration of its citizens to foreign territories.

“Curbing illegal migration into the country is a priority since it has serious security, economic and societal ramifications,” it said.

The government said it has been issuing instructions from time to time to all states and Union territories on the need to detect and deport Bangladeshi nationals found to be staying in India.

The Centre, however, said it has developed a mechanism to identify the doubtful voters by listing their names in category “D” who are neither allowed to vote nor stand for any elections.

“Identification of persons with doubtful Indian nationality in the electoral rolls began with the intensive revision of electoral rolls in 1997 -- persons who could not provide evidence in favour of their Indian nationality at the time of verification were marked as “D” in the electoral rolls so as to indicate their doubtful/disputed nationality status and these cases were referred to the competent tribunal for determination of their nationality.

“Such D voters are neither allowed to contest elections nor cast votes during elections. The electoral rolls figures from 2005 are accurate and authentic.

“Any so called abnormal growth, in the electoral rolls does not imply that the rolls contain the names of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants and the contention made regarding presence of illegal Bangladesh migrants in the electoral rolls is completely presumptuous,” the Centre claimed.

According to the government, to curb illegal infiltration it has strengthened the BSF equipping it with modern and sophisticated equipment/gadgets; raising of additional battalions, intensified patrolling and taken up other measures.

It said 36 foreigners tribunals have been set up to detect, declare and deport foreign nationals who have illegally infiltrated into Assam after the cut-off date of March 24, 1971.

“The government is committed to the detection and deportation of illegal migrants of post 24th March, 1971 in conformity with the provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and Foreigners Tribunal Order 1964 through the 36 foreigners tribunals,” it said.

Who is asking them to delete D-voters on the basis of religion? They are D-voters because they couldn't prove their Indian citizenship, not because they are Muslims or Hindus or for that matter anybody else. Its clear that the Congress is trying to give this exercise a communal face.

from:  Pranjal Barman
Posted on: Aug 11, 2012 at 23:39 IST

Now they are fighting with Bodos, but still given 'D' status.surely today's 'D' status will be totally 'Destructive' for future. Illegal immigrants are fighting for land today,tomorrow they will fight for voting and day after tomorrow they will contest election on behalf of supporting central government(which is showing support with this 'D' status).There is an intense need from center to show some spine in atleast one issue or face defeat in upcoming election.

from:  Vikram
Posted on: Aug 11, 2012 at 00:36 IST

It is pathetic to see indians suffering because of congress party's vote bank formula. I cannot believe they will even bring in migrants and allow them to kill poor indians

from:  Raj
Posted on: Aug 10, 2012 at 23:09 IST

By allowing these migrants,in this case 40 lakhs,what value are we adding to the Indian System? -- Nothing
Actually there are not derogatory to our system,as we have surpulus human capital and we have lot of thing to do for our existing citizens.
Just try to deport them to there native country promptly,please congress stop all these vote bank politics!!

from:  darshangr
Posted on: Aug 10, 2012 at 22:54 IST

It needs political will and pursuance to weed out the illegal migrants.
If the government continues to slumber, consequences are going to be
more as the gap between living conditions between the two countries is
increasing rapidly. It's a socio-economic problem at the root.
Unfortunately we are still lagging behind in closing porous border in
the eastern side. Above all the politicians should rise above the vote
bank politics and serve the cause of the Nation.

from:  M M Hegde
Posted on: Aug 10, 2012 at 21:44 IST

Still the CONGRESS govt doesnt find it wise to tell SC how many
it has deported using its "36 foreigners tribunals". Yes??? Congress is
a joke and bodos are eventually going to end up vacating their own land
after incessant bloodshed. PM Manmohan Singh should resign than destroy
this country.

from:  Pavithran
Posted on: Aug 10, 2012 at 18:56 IST

Vote bank politics ensures that illegal immigrants from Bangladesh stay in the country. The photo shows the pathetic condition of the Bodos victims of the recent clashes.

from:  krishna
Posted on: Aug 10, 2012 at 18:45 IST
Show all comments
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh

Other States






Recent Article in National

Mr. Gandhi’s whereabouts is a subject of conjecture and jibes with ‘missing person’ posters.

Congress polls to conclude in Sept.

Speculation continues on ‘if and when’ Rahul Gandhi will take charge »