News » National

Updated: January 12, 2013 02:49 IST

Debates on the pages of The Hindu

Madhava Doss
Comment (4)   ·   print   ·   T  T  

(February 11, 1897)

Mr. Swamijee's attitude towards theosophy

Swami Vivekananda's opinion of the Theosophical Society and his patronising reference to Mrs. Besant is not what an earnest Hindu, who has known the Society and Mrs. Besant, was prepared to hear. He is reported by the local Times to have said that ‘I lectured to her (Mrs. Besant) in London for some time.’ We heard that he lectured at the London Blavatsky Lodge once or twice; but that she was lectured to by him must be news to many and to Mrs. Besant more than to anybody else. Mrs. Besant had been a Theosophist and recognized preacher even to the leading Theosophists, who had studied Hindu religion before the Swami ever went to London. Mrs. Besant is not credited by the Swami with much insight into Hindu philosophy or much knowledge of Hindu religion. The Swami had the candor to say that his knowledge of Mrs. Besant was very limited. Men like Mr. Justice Subramania Iyer, Sir K. Seshadri Iyer, Justice Mr. Ramchandra Iyer, and a host of others who have labored hard in translating Sanskrit religious works, and who have studied with devotion Brahma Sutras, Upanishads, and Gita with commentaries by Sankara and Ramanuja, have acknowledged her capability as a great teacher on Hindu religion. And if their words mean anything, surely Vivekananda’s estimate of her knowledge is grossly absurd. This does not speak well of the Swami’s fairness of judgement or of his humility. As to his belief in Mahatma, etc., he would have done well if he had refrained from hazarding an opinion instead of venturing to discredit a ‘most sincere’ woman as he calls Mrs. Besant, as well as those of her respectable and intelligent following who have pledged their beliefs in the Mahatmas. The Swami believes in the greatness of his Guru, Yoga, Samadhi, Initiation, Meditation, and all that. What does that lead to but to Occultism and Mysticism? If he thinks they do not, then it is not Hinduism of our sages he preaches. He should have hesitated before insinuating that wisdom and Mahatmism begins and ends with his revered Guru.

He would be alienating the sympathy of all sincere men, of course, including a large number of Hindu Theosophists, who are his warm admirers, by his ill-judged pronouncement against the Theosophical Society and Mrs. Besant. A ‘sincere’ woman like Mrs. Besant is not likely to thank the Swami for his gratuitous and presumptuous advice that she would do well to forsake the ranks of the Theosophical Society. Mrs. Besant in true humility spoke of the Swami in her last Town Hall speech with respect and admiration, and the Swami assumes that he is the Guru and guide to Mrs. Besant. I am sincerely sorry for the Swami. I feel sure that he will hardly succeed in harming the Society, which deserved so well of the Hindu race; but I am afraid he would only forfeit the allegiance of a great number of his real Hindu admirers.

More In: National | News

Burn everything that is yours so that finally you have to go and beg
before others, for things probably more inferior than what you burnt.

from:  Viswas
Posted on: Jan 12, 2013 at 08:31 IST

Couldn't help but notice the author stirring up controversy without interview with
either side - just like the media stirring up Anna Hazare vs Kejriwal controversies

Also the author mentions that Hinduism is Occultism. Really?

from:  Arvind
Posted on: Jan 12, 2013 at 05:29 IST

Swami was the researcher of the self at that young age.He carried no ill
feeling for any one including Mrs.Beasnt.May be Mrs.Besant has not made
herself known at that time.Swami addressed commonly Theosophical society
inclusive of Mrs.Besant.He confessed he had little knowledge of
Mrs.Besant and even with limited knowledge he praised her on occasions.
It seems the whole article is a misunderstanding.

from:  Ashok
Posted on: Jan 12, 2013 at 04:08 IST

This is a needless debate. Both the Swami Vivekananda and Dr. Annie Besant are no more. People(a few who remembers them) have good opinion about both of them. Why do you want to change that opinion. After a few years nobody will even remember these two great persons of India.

from:  J.Nagasubramanian
Posted on: Jan 12, 2013 at 03:50 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor


Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh





Recent Article in National

Prices of petrol and diesel have been raised by Rs. 3.18 and Rs. 3.09 a litre (ex-Delhi) respectively, effective Saturday midnight. File photo

Petrol, diesel prices hiked by over Rs. 3 a litre each

In a jolt to consumers, oil marketing companies hiked the prices of petrol and diesel hours after the Union Budg... »