News » National

Updated: February 19, 2011 02:13 IST

CBI opposes dropping of conspiracy charge against Advani, moves Supreme Court

J. Venkatesan
Comment (2)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Senior BJP leader L.K. Advani.
Senior BJP leader L.K. Advani.

The Central Bureau of Investigation has moved the Supreme Court against a judgment of the Allahabad High Court upholding the dropping of conspiracy charge by a special court against BJP leaders L.K. Advani, Murli Manohar Joshi, Uma Bharti and 18 others in the Babri Masjid demolition case.

The Lucknow Bench of the High Court on May 20, 2010 dismissed the CBI's revision petition for a direction to proceed with the conspiracy charge against Mr. Advani and others.

Nine months later, the CBI has now filed the appeal with an application for condonation of delay. The Supreme Court has the discretion to accept or reject the appeal on the ground of limitation as it is filed well beyond the 90-day period.

Mr. Advani and 20 others faced charges in two cases arising out of two separate first information reports. In the first FIR, conspiracy alleged against “lakhs of unknown kar sevaks” was for the offence of demolition (case 197). The second FIR, which specifically charged Mr. Advani and other leaders with making inflammatory speeches leading to the demolition (case 198), was tried in a special court in Rae Bareli. The two cases were later merged and handed over to the CBI, which filed a composite charge sheet on October 5, 1993.

Technical flaw

However, due to a technical flaw, the two cases were revived by an order of the High Court on February 12, 2001. On May 4, 2001, the sessions judge dropped the conspiracy charge against Mr. Advani and others on the ground that case 197 related only to kar sevaks. This order was upheld by the High Court. Assailing the High Court judgment, the CBI said the trial court had erroneously concluded that Mr. Advani and 20 others were not entitled to be tried in case 197 but should be tried in case 198. This distinction was made on the ground that persons against whom only instigation and allied offences were made out should be relegated to case no. 198.

However, the persons who had indulged in the actual demolition should be tried in case 197, besides for snatching of cameras and assault on mediapersons.

The CBI contended that the bifurcation attempted by the trial court and approved by the High Court was completely erroneous in law. The offences of instigation, facilitation, the actual demolition of the disputed structure on December 6, 1992, and the continuous assault on the mediapersons all formed a single connected transaction and might also be a concerted conspiracy under Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code.

The error in the trial court and High Court judgments vitiated the fundamental principles of criminal jurisprudence that in a continuous criminal act which might attract various offences under the IPC, the transaction had to be viewed as a whole and evidence could not be adduced in two different courts, the CBI said.

As a result of the High Court judgment, approximately 200 more witnesses would have to be examined in case 198, in addition to their being examined as witnesses in case 197. This resulted in a serious miscarriage of justice and disabled effective trial, the CBI said.

The issue of justice to Babri Masjid is an issue of neutrality of Indian state and its 'secular' judiciary. Since last 60 years, the state with its judicial system has supported all efforts to convert Babri Masjid into Ramlala temple. It is a fact the state is equally involved in all crimes against Babri Masjid. Let us wait for more 20 to 25 years watching saffronization of the state. Finally I know there is no justice for Babri masjid because this is the decision of the state. Judicial activism is just a drama.

from:  Zubair Khan
Posted on: Mar 4, 2011 at 22:59 IST

The CBI's decision to oppose Allahabad High court's decision to drop charges against Mr.Advani has made it to the headlines of almost all the news channels. But the media has chose to remain tight lipped on Allahabad High court notice to Mr.Rahul Gandhi. Even The Hindu has not reported this news in its print version.

from:  Rajan
Posted on: Mar 4, 2011 at 17:31 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor


Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh





Recent Article in National

Air Force to get 38 more Pilatus basic trainers

The Defence Acquisition Council also appointed Goa Shipyard Limited as the lead agency to build 12 Mine Counter-Measure Vessels (MCMV) for the Navy. »