To many in Idinthakarai, the village that sits cheek by jowl with the nuclear plant, the entire idea is a betrayal. Others see brighter prospects. As the reactor prepares to go critical, Meera Srinivasan assesses the mood in the project area.
Seated at the entrance to her tiny home, R. Pramasakthi is busy rolling beedis. “What? Interview? We don’t need the nuclear plant,” she barked.
Asked why, the 35-year-old mother of four replied: “We saw a video at the church showing children with deformities caused by accidents at nuclear reactors. Ask anyone here, they will tell you that we don’t want the plant.”
To prove her point, Pramasakthi flagged down a young girl. “Tell her, do you need the plant,” she commanded the girl. “No, we don’t need the plant. It will cause diseases,” the girl replied flatly. What diseases? “Dengue,” the girl, a student of class IX, replied. “Our teacher told us.”
The girl went her way, and Pramasakthi, who was seated on the steps to get some breeze (Kudankulam, like most of Tamil Nadu, goes without power for 14-17 hours daily), got back to rolling beedis — something that most other women in the village do to supplement their family income. She rolls 44 bundles of 25 beedis each to make Rs. 100 a day. “I don’t go for the protests of late because the Rs.100 I make is crucial to support the family, but there is no change in my opinion. I am totally against it,” declared Pramasakthi.
She is among the hundreds of villagers who seem to be caught in a web of fear, anger and, in some cases, ignorance of the potential benefits and risks associated with the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Project (KKNPP), which is likely to be commissioned next month and is expected to produce 1,000 MW to begin with.
Officials of the Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL), which is executing the project, said that though there has been no communication internally on a specific date when unit one will be commissioned, there are clear signs of the pace of work accelerating during this final leg of construction.
Risk vs. Benefit
The plant, coming up at a cost of Rs. 14,000 crore, is expected to produce 2,000 MW through its two reactors, and seeks to help address the ongoing power crisis in the country. Tamil Nadu alone has fallen short of 4,000 MW.
While many sections of people have pinned their hopes on the plant and the promise of power, it is nothing more than an unfair deal to Balammal, a long-time resident of Kudankulam. “The benefit will go to everyone, but the risk will be borne by us alone. Only because we are poor,” the 73-year-old said.
The anxiety has begun creeping into classrooms as well, school teachers in the area said. “Their parents are summoned for the protests and sometimes, their fathers are picked up by the police. The children have very strong and opposing views on the issue, and they often argue among themselves in class,” said a teacher at the government school at Kudankulam. In a few cases, the stress manifests through a drop in performance in examinations, teachers said.
In addition to health hazards and the potential risk, a section of locals is worried about the lack of preparedness to face an emergency. This concern, perhaps, points to a possible meeting point for the government and the locals because even while emphatically voicing her objection to the plant, L. Rosalene Rajam said frequent safety drills ought to be organised. “Not once have I been called to participate in the drill. Since we don’t know what to do in case of an emergency, we panic every time there is a noise from that direction,” she said, pointing at the plant.
NPCIL campaign
The NPCIL has prepared a presentation, highlighting the need for nuclear power and the safety mechanisms put in place. Around 13,000 people have seen it so far, according to NPCIL officials, who said that making the highly technical presentation accessible was challenging. “We explain the concepts in Tamil and try our best to avoid jargon. It is a very safe plant and we want people to know that,” said S. Venkatesh, senior technical engineer.
Kudankulam, a small village in Tirunelveli district, is barely 20 km away from Kanyakumari, the southern most tip of the Indian peninsula. The roads connecting the villages around this coastal stretch are flanked by huge windmills making a tangential attempt at generating power, even as the plant itself readies for the ambitious target of 2,000 MW.
Closer to the date of commissioning, the plant resembles a fortress. Men and women attired in bright blue uniform, attached to the Rapid Action Force, sit at the first entry point. Further down the road, numerous Central Industrial Security Force personnel are posted at the giant gates at two subsequent points on the path to the site, guarding what has now become a storehouse of hope for many.
At the plant located just a few km away from where Rosalene resides, a very different mood prevails. The twin reactors with domes stand tall on the enclosed KKNPP premises that span 1,050 hectares by the Bay of Bengal. “Our technicians are working overtime, and all of us have been asked to focus our energies on completing work immediately,” said a senior official of the Human Resources Department at the site, where nearly 1,000 permanent staffers are currently employed.
Apart from the Russian experts, this contingent includes locals such as C. Vinayaga Perumal, a resident of the nearby Chettikulam village, who works as a technician in the project management system wing of the plant. After obtaining a diploma from an Industrial Training Institute, he was trained for two years and then gave a series of examinations before being made a permanent employee.
Having put in 10 years, he gets paid Rs. 45,000 a month now. “About 50 people from my village work as technicians here. There are about 55 from Kudankulam and one colleague is from Idinthakarai,” he said, clicking pictures of us near the plant with a DSLR. “This is just for our record.”
For youngsters like him, the plant bears much more than the promise of power. It has meant a job opportunity that he values. But ask villagers at the adjoining Idinthakarai— the fishing hamlet that has been the heart of the protests led by S.P. Udayakumar — and they call it betrayal.
“I would rather die. The sea has been our source of livelihood for years and I cannot do anything else,” said Rayappan a fisherman. Squatting by the shore and tweaking his net, he added: “We will continue protesting. Let’s see how they commission the plant.”
Keywords: Kudankulam nuclear power project, KKNPP, Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited, Industrial Training Institute, Idinthakarai









This is not the first nuclear plant that goes into operations.
there were many operating plants in the country. There also the
situation is not different. there were people around and the same risk
element was there. but people accepted it. This new awareness may have
come though unknown sources.There was so much delay when the country is
suffering for shortage of power.The political leaders should explain
away all the fear and anger and convince them the benefits accruing to
them due to power generation from the nuclear plant.cutting across
party lines all political parties should persuade the protesting
neighbourhood and clear the way .
For those supporting nuclear plants, move yourself & your family to adjoining ares of nuclear plants and spend next 20-30 years tehre and then support nuclear plants & its postive benefits to the society. Its easy to talk about benfits to overall India by sitting somehwere remote or even overseas.
If the government had/has any foresight, instead of making India dependent on nuclear fuel (for the plants) and technology on foreign countries (what if they blackmail India on international issues India opposes), they would invest at least a 10th of the costs of these extremely expensive projects (14,000 crores on one plant????) on alternative energy - solar, wind, geothermal, bio mass (using sewage) and make India a world leader in these technologies.
There is no doubt that there is a need for energy sources and clean ones.
It is an opportunity for India to invest in its future using its greatest resources - brain power - to become a world leader in alternative energy.
What is the real penetration of solar energy in a country which is so freaking hot, not to speak of wind, geo thermal, etc?
we need some visionary leaders.....not corrupt, kickbackers (commission sychophants)
I also agree the same that nuclear energy is very important for all of us, we don't have alternative for that. I find the problem is with the education because many people are innocent. they do not do the same just by their own self. it is not their view points. these views are influenced by some one else. and the awareness for telling that nuclear energy good for them(people of kudankulam) in not a cakewalk.....
The discharge of liquid and air-borne radio active effluents from nuclear power plants has environmental impact and we do hear about unmonitored releases due to human or technical flaws.The radio active discharge in the form of diluted tritium comes from the boron used by reactors for neutron absorption to help control chain reaction, is also produced from the splitting of u235 in reactor core or when heavy water or lithium in the coolant absorb neutron. It has been found that plant releasing diluted concentration of tritiated water contaminates groundwater. May be due to tech. improvement the dangers posed by effluents has been reduced.But the people living near the plants have rights to demand protection from exposure to radiation from the nuclear cycle as it involves radionuclides and other r.a materials. Their concern for the plant's security and emergency preparedness in the form of disaster management is justified.They may be ignorant but they cant be taken for granted.
It is very apparent that science teachers have failed to inculcate a scientific spirit and temper in the children. A scientific temper has long been a cherished dream since Nehruvian days. It is desperately required now to banish fears in the minds of young and future citizens of India. The governmnet should also train the villagers on emergency responses as they will be affected the most, if god forbid, something goes wrong.
After three mile island in USA no more power projects in America. After Chernoboyl no one thinks of the nuclear powe in Europe… Japan is the greatest example of the grave danger nuclear power Nature is given us solar power, then why go in for nuclear power I Plead on my bended knees for the safety of the people of Tamil Nadu. Please halt Kundankulam project. You are saviour Tamil masses. Therefore don’t, don’t commission Kundandulam project - Justice V.R. Krishna Iyar source counter currents.org
I support the struggle of in Kundandulam. It is against our mother earth and people. It is totally a unjust project and hence should be scraped. We have enough safe ways of producing energy and stop this madness – S Usha – researcher working on sustainable energy - source counter currents.org
None other than Ex-President Sri Abdul Kalam has said that the nuclear
power plant is save. It only needs teachers to disseminate the right
facts to school children. And how does the nuclear plant induce dengue.
This was the answer given by a school girl. For the sake of the well-
being of INDIA as a whole, the building of nuclear power plants is
important. INDIA does not have much fossil energy generating raw
materials, but there is a need for electricity !
To remove the fear from the minds of local people, it would be wise if some senior employees, scientists and security staff are settled nearby the plant.
Just today I received new petitions from Japan from the people of Fukushima who are
begging the world community to request their government to relocate their 300,000
children, 50% of whom are diagnosed with thyroid radiation and the situation is
worsening as local radiation levels are daily increasing and parents are worried about
their children's future. In a video circulating in the net entitled "S.O.S. from
Fukushima" one can hear and see their misery and despair. Yes all safety
mechanisms may have been put in but there is NO SAFETY MECHANISM for
something called HUMAN ERROR and worse still Mother Nature is increasingly
surprising us with unsurpassable disasters. This year NASA has predicted massive
solar storms as the sun prepares to switch it's magnetic poles (which happens every
twelve years) They expect a big one to occur anytime between now and May 2013.
Entire electrical grids could be burnt out for months. In this case how will we cool a
1000MW shut down fissioning reactor?
We expect more from educated leaders in the society. The crux of the argument is that
nuclear reactors do not leak radiation into the environment by any mechanism. It is a very
clean method of producing power. Coal based thermal power is very pollutive and ravages
the earth through mining.
But if there is a severe accident there can be very harmful consequences with nuclear
power. The issue is one of what steps have been taken to build in redundancies and
safeguards.
Focus on this question, and I am sure that there are good answers in kudankulam.
Waste Management was a big issue. They said KNPP waste would be taken to Russia according the agreement but later they said they have to undergo a Re hydration process in India itself. On an average 2000 Tons of Uranium is to be used and think what would the amount after few years since it may generate more radiation and we would be in a position to in heal it and create disaster to oceanic life and will even lead us to poverty.
Kudankulam is the only nuclear plant in India where more than 25000 people are living in the
Sterilized Zone and the big villages like kudankulam and Idinathakari are sharing the same compound wall of KKNPP. All other six sites in India there are no highly populated villages in the Sterilized Zone. So people who close to the reactor only will get scared. That is why protests in kudankulam.
The government needs to address the genuine concerns of the locals and not try to dodge the people and break the protest saying that these people are uneducated, foreign countries funding etc.
This is Strange advice from media houses like yours. Moreover, you show ignorance of ground issues in this case. The govt's own panel has recommended safety measures which have not been implemented. Just because Kalam gave a certificate does not mean you can start a Nuclear plant. Tomorrow Salman Khan will give a certificate and all his fans will say lets go ahead with the plant! Moreover it is time to ask the question if the central govt. has mandate to set up such projects in any community's backyard without the approval of that community. This is because it is now well known how decisions are made by politicians and whos interests are protected most. Also you talk about foreign funding for protests. This is laughable since the govt. supported by the media is day in and day out clamoring for foreign funding for all kinds of projects!! So how come it is acceptable to take foreign money to set up projects while it is not so for those who oppose these projects??
The fact is that power is consumed most by urban population. If nuclear power is good and devoid of any risks why not setup a plant in New Delhi?
Please Email the Editor