Lalu Prasad decried "outside" attempts to dictate terms to Parliament
Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) chief Lalu Prasad on Saturday came out strongly in support of the supremacy of Parliament and Constitutional principles and lashed out at attempts being made from “outside” to dictate terms to Parliament.
Hailing Parliament as the sacred temple of democracy, Mr. Prasad asserted that any attempt to cause damage to this temple would not be allowed to be made.
He questioned the need for a debate on the Lokpal issue saying a Bill in this regard was already before a Parliamentary Standing Committee.
“Is this government not violating the supremacy of Parliament by discussing a matter that is before a Standing Committee,” he said, while participating in a marathon discussion in the Lok Sabha on Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee's statement on issues relating to the setting up of the Lokpal.
In a speech laced with his characteristic rustic humour and wit, Mr. Prasad targeted those who were using derogatory language against political leaders and creating hatred for politicians and elected representatives of the people. Terming himself as a product of the JP movement and a keen student of political science, he did not spare the UPA government either, saying the government had made a mistake in first arresting Anna Hazare and then shifting him to jail.
Recalling the arrest of Bharatiya Janata Party leader L.K. Advani during his “Rath Yatra” in Bihar, Mr. Prasad, who was then Chief Minister of Bihar said that the leader was shown due respect and kept in a guesthouse.
Lauded and egged on by MPs, who cut across party lines, to continue to speak on the issue, Mr. Prasad said MPs should work for the strengthening of democratic institutions in the country. He said proceedings of the House should be sent to the Parliamentary Standing Committee, which was considering the Lokpal Bill.
Janata Dal (United) leader Sharad Yadav too stressed on the importance of Parliamentary supremacy. He wanted the Lokpal and Lokayuktas to be set up in the States simultaneously.
‘Maintain decorum'
Mr. Yadav criticised the remarks and gestures of film actor Om Puri and former police officer Kiran Bedi at Ramlila Maidan, saying people should maintain decorum.
From among the young members in the Lok Sabha, Minister of State for Commerce and Industry Jyotiraditya Scindia said that concern about corruption was not in Ramlila Maidan alone but that it was shared by all sections of the society and all citizens of the country.
“The concern is not in Ramlila Maidan alone. It is in villages and towns, among backward, Dalits and all sections,” Mr. Scindia said at the discussion.
He stressed that it was the UPA, led by Sonia Gandhi, which spearheaded the Right to Information (RTI) Act and other progressive measures. He pointed out that first interaction with the civil society was also taken up by the National Advisory Council (NAC), also led by Ms. Gandhi, while giving shape to RTI provisions.
BJP MP Varun Gandhi sounded caution about attempts being made to create a divide between Parliament and the people. Hailing Anna Hazare's anti-corruption crusade, Mr. Gandhi said that Mr. Hazare's initiative had sparked “something” among the youth of the country. While admitting that no single piece of legislation could be perfect, he said that the system had, over the years, failed the people. “The country needs massive funds in key sectors like health, infrastructure and education,” he said.
Shiromani Akali Dal MP Harsimrat Kaur said there was a perception among the people that political leaders had become the “fountainhead” of corruption. “People think we are not serious about weeding out corruption,” she said.
Making a passionate plea to redeem the credibility of democratic institutions such as Parliament, she pitched for a strong Lokpal Bill. She emphasised the need for addressing the “grey areas” that bred corruption, and a strong political will to change the system and make it people-centric.


Comments:
Standing Committees are a ploy usually employed by the clever politicians to side step and procrastinate on an issue they really don't want to tackle now, hopping they can extend it past the next election! Thankfully, they are caught out this time around!
Lalu Prasad Yadav perhaps doesn't know that the parliamentary system of democracy came into existence because of the realisation that debate and decision making cannot be done by all the people together and therefore a small group of representatives has to be elected by the people to represent them. In the very nature of things therefore, people have every right to tell their representatives what to do. It is not intended that people elect their representatives every 5 years and then give them full freedom to do whatever they like irrespective of whether what they do reflects the will of the people or not.Mr.Prasad has squandered his reputation as a man of the common people.
Parliment is supreme because it was given power to uphold Constitution and the welfare of the Indian Citizens; all rights benefits accrues to the the Parliment, it members and authorities aiding it is in consequence of that solumn duty; and not otherwise. In these over sixty years of our Rebublic Rule can any of these honourable menmbers consiously say what tangible act was done to erradicate corruption amoung them, except an excuse of coalation compulsion. Corruption in other places or by otheres donot have direct relevance to the masses. Further election of aperson can not be presumend to carry a nonstop authority for full period of the tenure; insanity and so many causes may take away ones' right; If so why not the peoples' involvement,or their expression through public rallies.
I have seen the live coverage of Mr. Lalu's speech in the Parliament yesterday. He was talking as if he is in public meeting.He was showing disrespect towards the people who came forward to participate the Anti Corruption Movement.He is already trapped in fodder scam so we do not expect in our favor.
I think in JanTantra people are supreme. We have examples of Syria, Yemenia and others. All revolutions are because of peoples will.
Yes it is right that the parliamentary supremacy should be maintained, but at the same time the parliamentarian should have brought the Lokpal Bill long back 1960, that's why Anna Hazare like people become heroes. Who allowed this situation to arise, only our parliamentarians who only wanted to loot the country and accrue assets for their wards. Now Mr.L.Prasad is taking about parliamentary supremacy and where was he for the past 60 years, sleeping under the desk. All of a sudden, he got enlightened and taking about parliamentary supremacy. Useless corrupt fellows.
Lalu speaks so much about Parliamentary supremacy because it is an institution which was all along protecting him and people like him, but now Team Anna has proved that people are supreme.
Laloo has studied political science???Its really a news to me! He spit his anguish to see that a common man has cornered the 40 year fooling tactics of the government. Unlike before the very fact that sense of the house has been registered before sending to the standing committee, the floor has but to pass this bill this time and cannot fool around by lapse of validity! Laloo will be accountable soon and this is his worry, Whatever one may say. Anna has ensured that this time the bill has to be passed and not otherwise. Laloo was the comedian who has put some ease and his intervention has no more value.
Lalu is like a kettle calling pot black ! Lalu appears to care so much for democracy and supremacy of parliament, does he remember his autocratci, rather dictatorial rule in Bihar as its Chief Minister. And remember, when he had to go, he installed Rabri Devi as Chief Minister, a totally un-educated or rather illiterate wife of his as Chief Minister of Bihar as if he was King of Bihar and he can do whatever he wanted to. Imagine him lecturing Parliament on democracy and constitutionality of any measure. I can simply laugh, laugh at this Ghaschara Chor. Like is Hamam Me Sab Nange Hai. One lecturing others on constitutionality -what insignificance the Indian democracy has been reduced. Now we are ruled by these people.! God save India from her such Leaders !
k vijayakumar and v.subbarao are absolutely justified in their comments.to achieve supreme goal any thing which is a hindrance to be neglected for the benefit of human development.
Some of the leaders are not tolerate that they are also comes under the Lokpal Bill,,for they can not survive more here and making the people Fool and elected by the money power.How they get return back their money if they are n't making scam practices....u just see the past political history of those Leaders,,ultimately they shouting ab kya hoga,,,hamara ham to kahinke nehi rahe..no ghotal no money then no power.
Laloo and Sharad yadav should thank the voters that they have been still given opportunity to raise/support people demand in the parliament. People have now seen true faces of leaders during the Lokpal Discussion . Next general election will show them their rightfull place. Jai hind.
3 parliamentary supremacy can be maintained; as long as the word 'people' is not replaced by 'politicians' in the quote: Government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the Earth. By Abraham Lincoln? Parliamentarians followed the meaning of democracy; to the letter. Democracy is a form of government in which all eligible people have an equal say in the decisions that affect their lives. Ideally, this includes equal (and more or less direct) participation in the proposal, development and passage of legislation into law. It can also encompass social, economic and cultural conditions. INDIANS PROVED TO THE WORLD THAT OURS IS TRUE DEMOCRACY.
If Parliament is a temple then Lalu is a Devil. He should kicked outside first. As long as devils like Lalu is in Parliament, Lokpal is not going to Happen. We have a Chicken and Egg Problem. We need to kick out Lalu out of Parliament to get Lokpal in Action. But we need lokpal like central agency to kick him out. And hopefully Anna movement can break this deadlock. Lalu should be among the first persons charged by lokpal. I wonder what should be the punishment to Him. He is a Shameless crook. He does not even deserve to be called human much less a peoples' representative.
I don't have much knowledge of Parliament working.But one thing i wanna ask Mr.Lalu, Bihar people choose you for 15 yrs, you were representative of people.People see Bihari with hate, many time i experienced it. WHAT YO DID???? Nothing but gave one after one scam, You enjoyed your power. Have you ever asked the person,student forced to go out of its state for work,studies. NO why you be bother abt these.When you parliament power is forced by Indian people, you feel its against the constitution right. Then tell us all you elected representative of people what we should do when you gave corruption,scams,poverty,unemployment. When its comes to increase your salary whole parliament pass it within mins, and what about those Indian People who can't even have 2 times meal a day. Come out and debate with common Indian people then you will know. But you will not, sir its very easy to talk inside,come out and face the people then you will know who is taking away , whose rights.
Though the Yadavs are not used to speak responsibly when it comes to other important issues, what they have spoken in the parliament is absolutely correct and the BJP and the Left failed to take a hoslistic stand and given undue importance to the Anna style of agitation. The demand for anti-corruption law is a genuine one and who ever make the demand is welcome. But the style and manner of the demand should be democratic and within the frame work of constitution. The demand made by the so-called Team Anna that 'Jan Lok Pal should be passed by the parliament with in the month of August 2011' is nothing but arrogent, undemocratic and maoist. The Anna agitation had undermined the parlimentary democratcy and its privilige. Many political parties afraid of talking against the Anna agitation fearing they will get the wrath of a group of civil society. In-spite of that many MPs across the partylines had spoken against the style of the Anna agitation and they deserved to be appreciated.
If you have no time to watch comedy movie, watch Shri Lallu Yadav. He can make you laugh. He has frightened with acceptance of Anna as the only hero of present times in India. And that is why he made some speech which makes you only laugh at none but him Mr Lallu Yadav cannot win any election from any of the seat of Gujarat. Not only that he cannot win from Maharastra,UP or any other states. After Anna has become the real hero, if Anna is projected against Lallu Yadav for an election, Lallu cannot win even from his hometown!
This is why Lallu is more worried.
Aam Admi, Dear Lalu Ji, Parliament is an institution operated by the elected representative of people for the people. People are supreme who elect the persons considering they will behave like saints to maintain the sacred tradition of the temple of democracy. Around 200 persons elected representative are corrupt and the cases against are pending in courts so how these person can be a supreme.Anna is supreme with his clean image.Try to learn from Anna. Requirement of the Saintly person is sacrifice (Kurbani).Change is required to ensure that right person shall enter in Parliament so mend yourself.
Dear Mr. Lalu Prasad Parliament is NOT supreme, but the Constitution is. As guardians of the Constitution, we expect you to uphold the principles of parliamentary democracy without violating our rights - one of them is our right to express our views without fear. Our right to live (without corruption being perpetrated by all, including but not limited to our elected representative) honorably is chief among them too. Having been caught with their hands in the till, we have reason to believe all those who oppose the Jan Lok Pal or Cong Lok Pal or Seshan Lok Pal or Aruna Lok Pal or scheme to make any or all versions of the Lok Pal as a weak, toothless piece of legislation, are exercising their vested interests to deny us our rights. Kindly keep your sermonizing to election days and we will see to it that our voices continue to be heard as vocally as we want.
Lallu and Family made a mockery of democracy in Bihar and suddenly now he remembers he is a M P. Great Leader isn't he?
Why people at large should believe the institution of Standing commitee. The committee which is going to scrutnise Lokpal bill has members who are chargesheeted in the court for corruption. Like Lalu ( fodder scam) and amar singh (Cash for vote). Parliment needs to get rid of tainted members before it should claim to be representative of the people of India.
1)Surprised that the alleged product of JP movement Mr. Laloo , the movement which challenged the democratic framework now sings a tune of protecting the supremacy of the Parliament. 2) With the 'chara' 'ghotala' sticking on him, is he also a member of the standing committee which will hear the rationale of the Lokpal bill, ?????
our parliment is manufacturing crooks and scamsters than quality leaders if any party holds the mp numbers enough to destabilise the govt then your innocence is taken for granted, scamsters take shelter under democracy,democracy exists only in the name only monarchy prevails lalu will handover the bation to his wife she will handover it to her siblings and it goes on.
If the parliment is dominated by corrupt MPs, where should ordinary people go? Why people elect corrupt candidate as a MP?? only because they have to choose between more corrupt and less corrupt. Why political parties give tickets to corrupt ones? Because fighting an election in INDIA requires lot of money. And these corrupt canditates are capable of using money and muscle power for fighting the election. Why money is required for fighting the election?? Because there are 14 to 15 lakh voters for loksabha costituency. The candidates are of mediocre charecters, to whome most of the voters don't know. Secondly, not finding suitable candidate, almost 40 to 50% voters decide not to vote.the candidate has to use modern marketing techniques to become famous amoungst voters & increse the turnout in their favour. Out of 543 MPs of LOKSABHA 514 (95%)are elected with less than 40% votes of total no of electors. Where is the peoples' mandate??????????
Parliament can be supreme, the parliamentarians are not. It is them parliamentarians who bring shame to the parliament. How many times we have seen unruly scenes inside. The system of democracy means that each MP represent the opinion of citizens in his constituency in the parliament. How many times has an MP discussed any pre-legislative issue with the people he represent? I haven't heard of any. I dare say a majority of MPs do not even understand the legislation they help enacting !!!.
Many have explained nicely Lalu's question. I will like to ask only one question. What is Lalu's expectation? How many fodder scam MPs he wants in standing committee?
Lalu......symbol of corruption....check his background.. 20 years ago.....what was he?......and what is he now?....
This guy is the biggest corrupt crook on the planet!
Many MPs and MLAs have an impression that once they are elected, there is total impunity and are free to indulge in wrongful acts and amass money. They see entering parliament is the gateway to personal enrichment materially. How this perception has developed? Who is responsible for it? I would say the electorate as well as those at the highest office of president and Prime Minister and Chief Justice. Because they are the ones who could have put their foot down and nothing of this sort is permissible.
Parliament is sacred - of course, but not with people like him and Arjun Singh around. As suggested by Anna, his next step should be towards Poll reforms. People with dubious character are our law makers. Parliament should be rid of politicians with immoral character.If this happens, then we can call the parliament a sacred place, not otherwise.
Tall talk for a guy who stole fodder to spin money!
Laloo giving a sermon on Corruption.Isn't it ironical.Yes,the Parliamentarians were needed to jolted. For too long,they have taken the people for granted.After getting elected,they thought they could get away with anything. MPs can't get immunity from what they do outside Parliament.They have to be brought within the ambit of Lokpal. Laloo and his ilk in the name of democracy have fooled people for too long.Now it's time for accountability. It's surprising that he is a Lohiate and follower of JP.Yet as CM of Bihar for 15 years did nothing apart from looting the State and amassing huge personal fortune. BTW,Parliament is NOT supreme.In the preamble,which is the soul of Constitution,it states that WE the people of India...So much for Pol Sc student...