News » International

Updated: December 12, 2010 05:53 IST

Digvijay, Antulay statements showed “crass political opportunism”: U.S.

Narayan Lakshman
Comment (5)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
The cable by the WikiLeaks contained a candid and sharply critical review of Congress party politics following the Mumbai terror attacks.
The cable by the WikiLeaks contained a candid and sharply critical review of Congress party politics following the Mumbai terror attacks.

Unites States embassy officials in New Delhi described as “crass political opportunism” the statements made by senior Congress party leaders such as Digvijay Singh and A.R. Antulay, in the immediate aftermath of the Mumbai terror attacks of November 2008.

The comments were revealed this week by WikiLeaks, the whistleblower website, which is publishing thousands of private diplomatic cables that it obtained from the U.S. State Department.

The cable in question, which contained a candid and sharply critical review of Congress party politics following the Mumbai attacks, was authored by the U.S. embassy on December 23, 2008 and sent to the Secretary of State in Washington.

In the cable, U.S. officials said that the willingness of Congress leaders to support “outrageous” comments by erstwhile Minority Affairs Minister Mr. Antulay, propounding a conspiracy theory behind the killing of Maharashtra Anti-Terror Squad Chief Hemant Karkare, reflected a cynical political calculation by the party that proved once again that many party leaders were “still wedded to the old identity politics.”

The context of the U.S. diplomats’ criticism was that Mr. Antulay sparked controversy on December 17 with comments insinuating that the killing of Mr. Karkare by the Mumbai terrorists was somehow linked to Mr. Karkare’s investigation of “Hindu terrorists” in the September 2008 Malegaon blasts case.

In that case authorities had arrested eleven Hindus, including an Indian Army Lieutenant Colonel, of whom police had identified five as having ties to the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party and two others as having ties to Sangh Parivar organisations.

Following Mr. Karkare’s killing, which U.S. officials termed a “remarkable coincidence,” the cable noted that Mr. Antulay had fanned the flames of controversy when he said, “Superficially speaking they had no reason to kill Karkare. Whether he was a victim of terrorism or terrorism plus something, I do not know.”

The cable further quoted Mr. Antulay as saying, “Unfortunately his end came. It may be a separate inquiry how his end came... There is more than what meets the eyes.”

While U.S. officials praised some segments of Congress leadership, including Home Minister P. Chidambaram, for officially dismissing Mr. Antulay’s comments and distancing the party from them, they attacked Mr. Digvijay Singh’s comments on December 21, when he said, “I don’t think Antulay made a mistake. What he asked for is a probe. What is objectionable in his statement?”

The U.S. embassy noted that the BJP had reacted to Mr. Singh’s statements by shouting slogans, and staging a walkout in Parliament three days in a row, and demanding a formal clarification from the government.

Further U.S. officials noted that emboldened by the equivocation, Mr. Antulay had refused to apologise or retract his statements and instead went on to argue that they reflected the views of a large segment of the Muslim population.

Overall, the U.S. diplomats said, while cooler heads eventually prevailed within the Congress leadership, it chose to pander to Muslims’ fears and the episode demonstrated that the party would readily stoop to the old caste (and) religious-based politics.

“Cable on Modi may have been doctored”

PTI reports from New Delhi:

Mr. Singh on Saturday expressed doubts over WikiLeaks' claim that Lashkar-e-Taiba planned attack on Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi and alleged the document could have been tampered with by “capable people” in the Bharatiya Janata Party.

“WikiLeaks is open to tampering and I must say that people in the BJP are quite capable of tampering with the document like the Pakistani media did,” Mr. Singh told reporters here.

It is really sad that the ruling party is acting in such an insensitive manner towards an issue such as national security. Unfortunately, the political climate in the country is such that the average Indian finds himself branded pro-BJP the moment he asks for more stringent security measures and suggests actions for achieving them, or conversely, pro-Congress the moment he questions certain ideologies of the BJP. There is hardly any space for the educated, forward-looking citizens of the country, who are dismayed by both the Congress and the BJP alike, to express themselves more objectively without falling necessarily into either of the two camps. Only the media can help channel the 'middle' voices.

from:  Luhar Sen
Posted on: Dec 13, 2010 at 09:56 IST

Senior Congress leaders at the behest of the congress leadership, trying to project themselves as the chanmpions of the minorities has stoopped so low that a well decorated and respected law enforcement officer's tragic death, is a tool in their hands for political point scoring. The sad part is that the Hindus in the country are so apathetic that they allow this kind of statements to go unchallenged. The protection of the Hindus is not the duty of the Sangh Parivar alone but of all Hindus. Congress leadership (dead or alive) used this apathy for their own benefit. Singh and Anutlay are not exceptions but the rule.

from:  Mani Sandilya
Posted on: Dec 13, 2010 at 00:10 IST

Media , both Tv and Paper should show some responsibility by not letting the comments made by some mindless greedy people touching the headlines. Its time to make laws to contain people from misusing the constitutional freedom of speech in an attempt to destabilize the communal harmony.

from:  Prem
Posted on: Dec 12, 2010 at 23:56 IST

Thanks to Wikileaks, we have independent confirmation of the low levels to which some politicians will stoop to for the sake of votes. Investigations carried out by Indian agencies and the FBI have proved beyond reasonable doubt that the Mumbai attacks were carried out by terrorists trained and dispatched by Pakistan and that these terrroists killed Mr. Karkare. Yet, Mr. Digvijay Singh has again tried to stoke the communal cauldron by repeating his controversial and irresponsible comments regarding the killing of a brave police officer.

from:  krishna
Posted on: Dec 12, 2010 at 16:59 IST

What else can we Indians expect from this party. Instead of uniting its citizens in the fight against terrorism we are time and again planted with seeds of venom for political gain. Why else was this so-called leader waiting for 2 years to speak up, suddenly he rises form slumber at the time when Congress is facing worst charges of outright corruption. Even a child can say he was directed in a sinister way. Indians can only weep at this beligerent attitude in dividing us in the name of religion. Hope Mrs. Karkare wisdom can put an end the dark designs in this party.

from:  Suresh Kumar
Posted on: Dec 12, 2010 at 06:14 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor







Recent Article in International

Sri Lankan President appoints Tamil as Chief Justice

Sri Lanka on Friday appointed Justice K Sripavan, an ethnic-Tamil, its new Chief Justice, days after his predecessor Mohan Peiris was ask... »