The story of the London-listed Lonmin's Marikana mine shootings is that of a trade union that cosied up to big business; of an upstart and populist new union that exploited real frustration to establish itself; and of police failure.
It is a story which exposes South Africa's structural weaknesses too. Poverty, inequality and unemployment lie at the heart of the shootings this week.
The Lonmin story starts with the 360,000-member National Union of Mineworkers, formed in the 1980s to fight apartheid labour laws. Under the leadership of Cyril Ramaphosa - ironically now on the board of Lonmin – the union became the biggest affiliate to the Congress of SA Trade Unions (Cosatu), a powerful ally of the ruling ANC.
Power politics
For more than a decade Cosatu has concentrated on socio-economic and political issues. Instead of organising on the shop floor it has harried the ANC government to adopt increasingly left-leaning policies. The NUM, one of the two biggest unions within Cosatu, has been at the forefront of these struggles. Over the past few years the NUM has been split by succession battles inside the ANC, with the current leadership campaigning for ANC President Jacob Zuma to win a second term. The union has paid a heavy price for this.
At the Lonmin mines its membership has declined from 66% of workers to 49% and it has lost its organisational rights. Disgruntled and expelled union leaders had in the meantime started a new union, the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, and were organising on the NUM's turf.
The NUM's achilles heel was that its relationship with mine owners and the Chamber of Mines had become too close. Its secretary, Frans Baleni, is a more strident critic of the nationalisation of mines than many business leaders. The union has also allegedly accepted wage settlements that tied workers into years of meagre increases.
Luring workers
The AMCU dangled a fat piece of fruit in front of the workers' eyes: rock drillers (who are the core of this strike and do the hardest work underground) earning R 4,000 a month were promised R 12,500 a month. The union's support in the Lonmin mines shot up to 19% by last month, and it embarked on an illegal strike to force its pay demand.
This week the strike turned violent. On the ground, armed workers are promising to "take a bullet with my fellow workers". The AMCU's leaders are preparing for war. The NUM has lost all credibility and is bleeding members. Its already well-paid secretary, Baleni, was awarded a salary increase of more than 40%
last year. NUM leaders have refused to get out of police armoured vehicles to address workers. Last year one of them was struck with a brick and lost an eye. They have no cogent plan to end the strike.
The police, too, have lost credibility. Although the indications are that they were shot at, a death count of 34 in three minutes suggests panic. A judicial inquiry is likely.
Lonmin saw its chief executive hospitalised with a serious illness two days ago. It is leaderless, then, and has no coherent plan to end the impasse. On Friday, it kept a stony silence after days of hapless statements.
The AMCU is also organising among poor workers and their shack settlement communities, which have become no-go zones for police. For these settlements, this is a strike against the state and the haves, not just a union matter. Joseph Mathunjwa, an AMCU leader, told workers yesterday: "We're going nowhere. If need be, we're prepared to die."
Justice Malala is a political analyst in Johannesburg
Copyright: Guardian News & Media 2012
Keywords: South Africa mining massacre, Marikana mine shootings, Congress of SA Trade Unions, Cosatu, AMCU
This whole situation is tragic but is a reflection on a violent South African society. The reporter fails to advise that in the time leading up to the shooting of the 'demonstrators' that two mine security personel were burnt to death in their vehicle, two policeman were brutally hacked to death and eight other people had been murdered by these 'demonstrators'. Nor that a witchdoctor had been giving them 'medicine' to make them invinciable to police bullets! The demonstrators, it appears (this hopefully will be made clear in an enquiry) advanced on the police. The police initally used tear gas and rubber bullets but had to use live rounds when that was ineffective. Put yourself in everyone of those policemen standing there. Faced with a drug crazed individual wielding a machette and a spear, what would you have done??? More the pity when at the end of the day I'm sure it will be shown that they were being used as pawns in someone's strategy to take over the Lonmin mine.
Why is a British company paying below subsistance wages in South Africa? It seems we need draconian labour laws in Europe because as soon as British Industry gets a chance they pay slave wages. The EU should ensure that all European companies pay their workers a living wage thus raising the living standards of the third world and preventing the kind of riot that led to this massacre.
The Lonmin massacre is really a disaster that all role players are not able to explain to the public. As an employee at Lonmin let me try and put things into perspective,NUM and Amcu are rivals but that did not fuel or contribute to this crisis.NUM has been ignoring the employees for a long time now which led to the emergence of Amcu especially at Karee division.Early this year Lonmin Karee employees(NUM)clashed with their regional leadership over the suspension of their respected leader whom was then fired at work and subsequently 9000 workers dismissed for unprotected strike.After the reemployment of some workers their fired leader was then given a job at the Amcu regional office and recruited a number of Karee workers.Now the recent uproar was neither organised by Amcu nor was it organised by NUM,but was a collective campaign taken by affected employees namely(Rock Drill Operators).This group of workers are from both unions and others non union members.
These are not miners, they are the "new and improved" slaves of apartheid.
Please Email the Editor