LIGHTS, CAMERA, CONVERSATIONAmong the low pleasures in life, few can top films about fellow humans beset by bees and killer fish and other generally horrific situations

The provocatively titled Piranha 3DD is, uh, a bust. It delivers neither on the first half of its title, nor the latter half — unless, of course, our censors had something to do with it. The film can be loosely described as Baywatch-meets-Jaws — lots of people in skimpy swimsuits jogging in the direction of the (3D) camera as nasty fish with pointy teeth target their well-toned flesh. As a big fan of the earlier film (which was simply called Piranha 3D), I was quite disappointed, and to explain why, I must share with you a deep, dark secret.

Every film critic has a vice, a fondness for a shockingly disreputable genre. I like these schlocky films where hubris-filled men get their comeuppance for playing God, and also the so-called “creature features”, where human beings become prey. Switch off the lights and pass the popcorn.

My favourite man-playing-God films include The Towering Inferno (man tries to play God and builds tallest skyscraper; it goes up in flames) and Deep Blue Sea (man tries to play God and cure Alzheimer’s with brain tissue harvested from genetically modified sharks; he’s reduced to fish food). There are few genuinely guilty pleasures like The Towering Inferno, which is worth the ticket price (or the rental price) simply to watch megawatt stars such as Steve McQueen, Paul Newman and Faye Dunaway pretend, by way of all that acting, that they signed on for reasons other than the fat sums of money they were being paid. It’s always a bonus when big stars are trapped in yawning chasms of land (Charlton Heston and Ava Gardner in Earthquake) or pursued by killer bees (Michael Caine and Katharine Ross in The Swarm).

The Birds may feature a similar plot — people evading avian assassins — but it’s too classy a film to qualify as junk. Its set pieces are thrilling constructions, and besides, the real stars aren’t Rod Taylor and Tippi Hedren (who weren’t all that big as stars anyway) but the director Alfred Hitchcock. For the creature feature with smaller stars and guiltier pleasures, we should look towards Alligator, which has the titular creature (a giant, naturally) that’s taken up residence in Chicago’s sewers and is polishing off people, or Anaconda, where Jennifer Lopez, frustratingly, survives being swallowed up by a monster snake (Rooting for specific people to die is one of the chief pleasures of the creature feature).

But there’s another kind of people-in-peril movie that I’ve begun to enjoy, and that’s the no-budget feature about being trapped in a specific situation. The best such film I’ve seen is Buried, where Ryan Reynolds wakes up to find himself in a coffin under the sands of Iraq. These films operate on a higher level than the big-stars-screaming-their-way-to-safety genre and the smaller-stars-becoming-animal-food genre. They envelop you in a queasy state of anxiety.

Unlike the laughable protagonists of those other films, we are actually invested in the survival of Ryan Reynolds, and while those other films remain distant viewing experiences, Buried makes us wonder what we’d do in this situation. (No one watching Alligator, on the other hand, is going to think, “Let me prepare myself for an eventual attack by a giant reptile lurking beneath my toilet.”)

Two other films of this nature that impressed me are Open Water and Frozen — and both play on our fears of what we’d do if stuck in these very plausible situations. In Open Water, a tourist couple is left behind in a shark-infested sea when the boat captain takes a wrong headcount and sails away with the others. And in Frozen, which was one of those serendipitous TV-channel discoveries, three friends are trapped in a ski lift (bad weather from above, circling wolves below) after the resort shuts down for the week.

I realise that in writing about Buried and Open Water and Frozen, I have deviated from my original premise of cheesy films about imperiled humans, but all these films are built on our primal fears about being stranded in situations where we are no longer in control, and against enemies (whether creatures or the elements) we have no natural defences against. It’s just that some of these films make us laugh, while the others make us grateful to return to a warm bed at night.