SEARCH

Friday Review » Art

Updated: June 6, 2013 13:36 IST

Debate over two 11th century Chola icons

A. Srivathsan
Comment (2)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Royal Couple : Bronze protraits of the Chola King and queen said to be Rajarja I and Lokamahadevi at the Sarabhai Foundation, Ahmedabad. Photo: Special Arrangement
The Hindu Royal Couple : Bronze protraits of the Chola King and queen said to be Rajarja I and Lokamahadevi at the Sarabhai Foundation, Ahmedabad. Photo: Special Arrangement

Claimed to be lost portrait sculptures of Rajaraja-I, Queen

The two 11th century bronze icons, labelled as Royal Couple at the Sarabhai Foundation in Ahmedabad, are now subjects of debate in the State.

The icons are claimed to be the lost portrait sculptures of Rajaraja-I, the Chola emperor who built the Brihadiswarar temple at Thanjavur, and his queen, Lokamahadevi. As preparations are under way to celebrate the millennium year of the temple, a government delegation has approached the Gujarat government and the museum officials seeking their return.

While the existence of bronze portraits of Rajaraja I and Lokamahadevi at the temple has not been disputed, its identification with the icons at Ahmedabad is not free of contestations. There is also another claimant to this honour.

Inscriptions in the Thanjavur temple mention of four bronze portraits that were set up during Rajaraja's period. Two of them are identified as the emperor builder and his wife. The inscriptions also give details of the measurement of the icons.

At present, in the Briahadiswarar temple, there is a bronze icon identified as Rajaraja and is under worship. T.G. Aravamuthan of the Madras Museum examined the icon as early as 1925 and found that the height did not tally with those mentioned in the inscriptions. It was not the original icon, but a later work done to perpetuate memory of the founder of the temple was his conclusion.

The original bronze icons were lost centuries ago and were never located.

What appears to lend credence to the claim that the two icons at the Sarabhai Foundation are Rajaraja-I and his queen are their identification as the Chola King and Queen by Dr. R. Nagaswamy and the dates he has assigned to them. Mr. Nagaswamy who has studied these icons thinks that they are datable to the 11th century – the period coeval to the Thanjavur temple. He also points to the crown over the head and the channa–vira mark on the King's icon that indicates its warrior status. However, scholars such as Douglas Barrett have assigned a different date.

Mr. Barrett, writing in The British Museum Quarterly in 1968, also thinks that the two original portrait bronzes are no longer in the temple. However, he is reluctant to accept that the bronzes found in the Sarabhai collection are the original portrait sculptures.

In his estimate, based on the inscriptions, the height of the Rajaraja's icon must be about 24 inches, but the icon in the Sarbhai Foundation is about 29 inches tall. The height of the queen icon, which must be about 20 inches according to the inscriptions, also does not tally.

Mr. Barrett also disagrees with the date. In his opinion, the icons do not belong to the 11th century but to the early tenth century. He finds the reverse side of the Queen's icon at the Sarabhai Museum to be identical with the reverse side of the Sita icon found at Paruttiyur that is datable to the late tenth century. Other art historians such as P.R. Srinivasan and C. Sivaramamurti have also assigned different dates to the Sarabhai icons. They date them to the early 12th century.

The bronze statues could have reached "Retreat" (palatial bungalow of the Sarabhais in Ahmedabad)much before Mrinalini Sarabhai's arrival in Ahmedabad after her marriage to Dr. Vikram Sarabhai. Probably it might have been brought by her father-in-law, Ambalal Sarabhai, who always had keen interest in antique items.

from:  Bindu G. Nair
Posted on: Sep 11, 2010 at 10:40 IST

This newspaper search all over the world to find someone - he may be a foreigner who has nothing to do with this issue, to disprove or cast aspersions on anything connected to Gujarat. The news item of Rajaraja chola bronaze portraits being in Ahemedabad came in another paper few days ago, whereas this newspaer waited for an opportunity to find a person who can dispute it. Karunanidhi was planning to invite Modi for the Raja raja chola celebrations, perhaps, this newspaper did not want that to happen, and trying to fish in troubled waters.

from:  Bala
Posted on: Sep 10, 2010 at 14:51 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

O
P
E
N

close

Recent Article in Art

Suraj Ghai Photo: Sushil Kumar Verma

Anonymity for a companion

Artist Suraj Ghai has got critical acclaim but commercial success has eluded him »