Business » Industry

Updated: March 1, 2013 14:55 IST

PC effect, long live the grey market

Anuj Srivas
Comment (4)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Individuals looking to buy the flagship models, the iPhones, Galaxies and Lumias, will still purchase without worry.
File photo
Individuals looking to buy the flagship models, the iPhones, Galaxies and Lumias, will still purchase without worry.

Trying very hard to not rock the boat translates into making at least one or two boo-boos along the way. In his bid to widen the tax net by targeting affluent individuals, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram has unwittingly hit the middle class the hardest with the increase in excise duty on mobile phones.

Ironically, the affluent will escape unscathed. Individuals looking to buy the flagship models, the iPhones, Galaxies and Lumias, will still purchase without worry. An extra thousand or two thousand rupees shouldn’t make too much of a difference.

Where the hammer will fall the hardest, however, is on the low-cost feature phone segment— a segment that has been created entirely by the middle-class looking to get the absolute best bang for the buck. Bear in mind, these phones (the Ashas, Micromaxs, Lavas) are looked at with an almost shrew-like mentality. The typical range is from Rs. 6,000 to Rs. 12,000, wherein the price tags, even decimal points matter.

According to the Indian Cellular Association, a typical 3G phone that comes at a price of Rs. 8,000 would cost around Rs. 400-500 more. So, where does the customer turn to in troubled times? An altogether different type of market – one the average Indian needs no introduction to— one that has a grey tinge.

The absence of a carrier-bundled system, that subsidises the cost of the handset, has made it such that phones sold in India are already more expensive than those their American counterparts. A further hike will only result in a red carpet being laid out for the grey market to make deep inroads into the system.

What is further contradictory, however, is how this move negates the Government’s goal of connecting its citizens to the Internet. Indeed, a free Wi-Fi system on select trains was proposed just days ago in the Railway Budget. How does reducing the ability to purchase Internet-accessing devices gel with the aims of the National Telecom Policy? Nevertheless, the bottom line is that mid-range mobile phones need to stop being categorized as luxury items. Its economic-booster effect alone disqualifies such labelling. In the meanwhile, the outlook brightens for the grey market.

This article has been corrected for an editing error.

The article almost sounds like an endorsement of grey market. The Author should not forget the facts that while it may be cheaper to buy products in the grey market, they do not come with the same warranty and after sales service provided by the genuine resellers. So in the long run paying Rs. 500 extra for a normal cell phone will be a better option. Many service centres actually decline to accept these products unless it is bought from outside the country on a genuine warranty. As for iphones and other costly stuff, people who can afford don't actually care! Carrier bundle systems don't necessarily subsidise customers, they infact squeeze more out of them over a longer period. Yes, PC should have set Rs. 7500 as the lower limit and not Rs. 2000.

from:  Kuriakose
Posted on: Mar 1, 2013 at 13:03 IST

Nice one ANUJ SRIVAS ...

We speak business on numbers but they do deceive in Indian
context.33,000 is just 10% increase over 3000 so is 3300 over 3000,
But the extra 300 from a middle class man makes him think over it 100
times but 3000 in former case just shrugs and pays for it as it is
just foregoing a party over a weekend.

Politicians need to grow from middle class to understand that an MBA
from HARVARD doesn't teach that.

from:  Anil Garlapati
Posted on: Mar 1, 2013 at 10:41 IST

The other option is to realise that life doesn't stall if you don't have
the latest model phone.

from:  kk
Posted on: Mar 1, 2013 at 08:19 IST

What is this National Telecom Policy for? BSNL Broadband plan price also increased effective today!

Why buy Nokia, Samsung, Apple?
May be its to promote Kapil's Aakaash tablet!!!

from:  Sankar
Posted on: Mar 1, 2013 at 07:35 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Commodity prices

Take a look at the prices of various commodities in Chennai here»





Recent Article in Industry

The Commission said it is of the view that prima facie the conduct of Ola amounts to abuse of dominant position.

CCI orders probe against Ola Cabs for predatory pricing

A detailed investigation has been ordered by the regulator after it prima facie found evidence of Ola violating the competition norms. »