The Hindu : Front Page : A.P. quota for sections of Muslims quashed

Online edition of India's National Newspaper
Tuesday, Feb 09, 2010
ePaper | Mobile/PDA Version

Front Page

Front Page

A.P. quota for sections of Muslims quashed

Legal Correspondent

HYDERABAD: In a significant judgment having national ramifications, the Andhra Pradesh High Court on Monday struck down the four per cent reservation provided by the State government to selected sections of Muslims in education and public employment.

These sections were categorised as additional “E” group and included among the existing Backward Classes enjoying reservation, first through an ordinance and then legislation. Five judges on the Bench allowed the writ petitions challenging this Act 26 of 2007, while two differed with this view. The report of the A.P. Commission for Backward Classes, which was relied upon by the government for extending the reservation, came in for severe criticism by the judges.

Declaring the A.P. Reservation in favour of Socially Educationally Backward Classes of Muslims Act, 2007 “unsustainable,” the five judges said the Act “is religion-specific and potentially encourages religious conversions.” The majority judgment pronounced by Chief Justice A.R. Dave said the government’s action was based solely upon the findings and recommendations of the report of the Commission, and the procedural error committed by the Commission was fatal to its report and consequent recommendations.

Chief Minister K. Rosaiah directed Advocate-General D.V. Seetharama Murthy to immediately take action for filing a Special Leave Petition in the Supreme Court. He reiterated the government’s commitment to provide 4 per cent reservation to Backward Class Muslims. Barring the BJP, all political parties expressed concern at the judgment and wanted the government to take steps to restore the quota.

This is the third time the government is facing an embarrassment over a quota for Muslims. To keep its election promise, the government issued an administrative order in 2004 providing 5 per cent reservation for all Muslims, relying on a report by the A.P. Minorities Finance Corporation. This was struck down by the High Court. The government then constituted a BC commission and, based on its report, brought about the enactment in 2005, which was again rejected by the court.

Printer friendly page
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Front Page