Online edition of India's National Newspaper
Friday, Jul 01, 2005

About Us
Contact Us
Opinion
News: Front Page | National | Tamil Nadu | Andhra Pradesh | Karnataka | Kerala | New Delhi | Other States | International | Opinion | Business | Sport | Miscellaneous | Engagements |
Advts:
Classifieds | Employment | Obituary |

Opinion - News Analysis Printer Friendly Page   Send this Article to a Friend

Health as someone else's wealth

P. Sainath

Many in Vidharbha, like millions elsewhere, have simply stopped seeking medical help for their ailments. They just cannot afford it. Some farmers have mortgaged land to pay health bills.



TOO COSTLY TO FALL ILL: Like millions of other Indians, Shamrao Khatale in Wardha has simply stopped seeking medical help of any kind for his ailments. He cannot afford it. — Photo: P. Sainath.

SHAMRAO AND Anjamma Khatale are in very poor health. But the two have simply stopped trying to do anything about it. "Doctors? Treatment? It's all too costly," says Shamrao. The couple in Ashti village, Wardha, have joined tens of millions of others in that decision. Up to 21 per cent of Indians no longer seek medical treatment of any kind for their ailments. (That is up from 11 per cent a decade ago.) They cannot afford it. "And, if we went to the doctor, how do we buy medicines," asks Shamrao.

Their son Prabhakar Khatale committed suicide last July. Like many others in farming, he was devastated by the ongoing crisis of that sector. "He ended his life because of his loans," says Shamrao. A second son, in deep depression following the tragedy, is in no state to look after his aged parents. He does not appear to be under treatment either.

Booming private healthcare

The booming — unregulated — private medical sector here gives a whole new meaning to the adage: health is wealth. The decline of whatever public health services there were means that poor people boost the profits of private hospitals and practitioners. Health is the second fastest growing component of rural family debt across the country. (India's per capita health expenditure is one of the lowest in the world. The state spends less than 1 per cent of GDP on health.)

In Waifad village of the same district, farmer Gopal Vithoba Yadav mortgaged his land to pay health bills. "Just 40 minutes in hospital cost me Rs.10,000," he complains. Many others have paid much more. But Yadav parted with the title deed to his nine acres as he needed cash. Successive bad years on the farm had ensured that. "I am in possession of the land," he clarifies. But "the title deed is in the hands of the moneylender."

His neighbour Vishwanath Jade has an eight-member family living off four acres. A spinal operation set him back by Rs.30,000. MRI scans a further Rs.5,000. Add Rs.7,500 for his room at the hospital and Rs.20,000 on medicines. And then a heap of travel costs. Within just a year, Jade had to pay bills of Rs.65,000. The kind of sums many such families deep in distress spend on health is staggering. Namdeo Bonde committed suicide last November unable to cope with the farm crisis. He, too, had large health bills. "He made three trips to Chandrapur, Yavatmal town and Wani," says his brother Pandurang in Kothuda village, Yavatmal. "In all, he spent around Rs.40,000 on health problems."

In other suicide-hit households we surveyed, too, health costs were a big burden. Rs.25,000-Rs.30,000 was a common enough figure. That in households owning two to four acres. And often in heavy losses, with farming slipping by the season. That is why Shamrao and Anjamma just stopped buying medicines. "At the government hospital," say the farmers in Waifad, "you get nothing."

On the other hand, "if we go to Nagpur," says Manoj Chandurvarkar, "we'd have to pay a fortune. People fear a hospital." Nagpur's private hospitals mostly reject the blood test reports or X-rays they take in from Wardha. Even if the reports are sound. The referral racket won't be denied its cut. "So we have to go through the tests all over again. Everyone gets a cut and is happy."

These "CT scans and medicines are for big people. We have no money," says Rameshwar Chardi, also a farmer. The uncontrolled private sector can charge any fee it fancies. The under-funded, ill-equipped and crumbling government hospitals seem a poor option to many. "The treatment was `free,'" laughs Santosh Isai in Malwagad. "But it meant little." He spent Rs.35,000 on medicines and care for his brother Ashok, a cancer patient. Isai sold three acres in this Yavatmal village to raise the cash. Then they ran out of money.

His friend Sandeep Kadam went straight to a private hospital. He spent almost Rs. 2 lakh on his father who died of TB. "That meant selling three acres," he says. About a third of the land holding of his large family. Like in neighbouring Andhra Pradesh, all this hits the farm community in the midst of a crippling agrarian crisis. Very few are able to attend to major health problems without taking loans for it.

Anjamma lies on the floor unwell and too weak to sit up. Shamrao sits on the bed, frail and infirm He is pleased he has cleared his dead son's dues. "We got rid of that debt so that his soul may rest in peace." Their own bodies, though, do not. Ill health has taken its toll. Neither, at their advanced age, can work and earn a living. But health comes at a price. A price they, and countless millions like them cannot pay. In Waifad, they bid us a cheery goodbye. "If you want to know about health," says one, "look at our farming. Then you'll know. We are all on saline drip, us farmers. Two years from now, we'll be on oxygen."

Printer friendly page  
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Opinion

News: Front Page | National | Tamil Nadu | Andhra Pradesh | Karnataka | Kerala | New Delhi | Other States | International | Opinion | Business | Sport | Miscellaneous | Engagements |
Advts:
Classifieds | Employment | Obituary | Updates: Breaking News |


News Update


The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2005, The Hindu. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu